Which insurance do you need, and which can you skip?

Short answer, as of

Insure the losses you could not cover from savings: injuring someone while driving (a legal requirement), losing your home, and your income stopping through death or long illness when others rely on it. Smaller, likelier costs usually cost less to pay from an emergency fund. Work, your bank or other policies may already cover some risks.

The test: could you absorb the loss?

An insurance premium pays for the claims, plus the insurer's costs and profit. So across everyone who buys a policy, more goes in than comes out. That trade is worth making for a loss you could not pay yourself. For a loss you could pay, carrying the risk yourself usually costs less over time.

Three questions sort most policies:

  1. How big is the loss, and could you cover it from savings or income without borrowing? A cracked phone screen or a vet bill usually can be. A house fire, years off work or a death in a family with a mortgage usually cannot.
  2. Does anyone depend on your income? A partner, children or a shared mortgage change the answer for life and income cover.
  3. Do you already have it? Work, your bank account and your existing policies often include cover you have forgotten.

Paying for small, likely costs yourself is what an emergency fund is for. The bigger the fund, the more you can carry yourself, for example by choosing a higher excess or a longer wait before a policy pays out.

CoverUsually needed byOften not needed by
MotorAnyone driving, or keeping a vehicle on the road: it is the lawPeople who neither drive nor keep a vehicle on the road
BuildingsHomeowners, and anyone with a mortgageRenters; most leaseholders in England and Wales, whose landlord insures the building
ContentsAnyone who could not replace their belongings from savingsPeople with little to replace, or enough savings to replace it
Life (term)People with a partner, children or a joint mortgage relying on their incomeSingle people with no dependants and no shared debts
Income protectionAnyone whose household relies on their pay, especially the self-employedPeople with generous long-term sick pay, or enough to live on without working
Critical illnessPeople who want a lump sum on diagnosis, on top of income coverPeople already covered for loss of income who do not need a lump sum
TravelAnyone travelling abroad, where a medical bill can be very largePeople already covered by a policy they hold, such as one in a packaged bank account

Cover the law or a lender requires

Motor insurance

You must have motor insurance to drive on UK roads, and third party cover is the legal minimum. Third party pays for injury to other people and damage to their property, not repairs to your own car. Third party, fire and theft adds cover if your car is stolen or burnt out. Comprehensive adds damage to your own car in an accident.

In England, Scotland and Wales a vehicle must stay insured unless it is kept off the road and declared off the road with a SORN (statutory off road notification). GOV.UK says the rules differ in Northern Ireland, where nidirect explains motor insurance.

Buildings insurance

Buildings insurance pays to repair or rebuild the structure of your home. GOV.UK's guide to buying a home in England and Wales says it is normally a requirement of having a mortgage, and that buyers arrange it by exchange of contracts, because they become responsible for the property at that point. The buying process differs in Scotland and Northern Ireland, and the solicitor handling the purchase will say when cover must start.

If you own a leasehold flat, the landlord usually insures the building and the cost comes through your service charge. In Scotland, where flats are not leasehold, each flat owner must have insurance covering their share of the common parts, for example through their buildings policy. If you rent, the building is the landlord's to insure. In every case, your own belongings are not covered by the buildings policy.

Cover for your income and your family

These pay out when you die or cannot work. They matter most when other people rely on your pay or you have a mortgage.

Life insurance (term)

Term insurance pays a lump sum if you die within a set period, for example until your youngest child turns 21 or the mortgage ends. If you outlive the term, it pays nothing. Whole of life cover, by contrast, pays out whenever you die, so premiums for the same sum are usually higher.

  • Level term: the payout stays the same throughout. It can suit replacing income for a family, or an interest-only mortgage where the whole loan stays outstanding.
  • Decreasing term: the payout falls over the term, usually in line with a repayment mortgage balance. Premiums are usually lower than for level cover of the same starting sum, but the payout may leave little over once the mortgage is cleared.
  • Family income benefit: a variation that pays a monthly income for the rest of the term rather than one lump sum.

Many policies also pay out early on a diagnosis of terminal illness, usually defined as a life expectancy of less than 12 months.

Writing a policy in trust means the payout goes to trustees for the people you choose, rather than into your estate. HMRC's inheritance tax form IHT410 describes policies payable to beneficiaries under a trust as not forming part of the estate, so the payout is not normally counted for inheritance tax. A trust is hard to change once set up. The inheritance tax guide explains the wider rules, and a solicitor can help if your affairs are complicated.

Income protection

Income protection replaces part of your income if illness or injury stops you working. The FCA describes policies as typically paying around 50% to 70% of income. They pay until you return to work, reach the retirement age you chose, die or reach the end of the policy, and some limit each claim to a set period, typically two or five years. The Financial Ombudsman Service says benefits are usually paid tax-free, which is one reason a policy replaces only part of your pay.

Two terms decide how much a policy is worth:

  • Deferred period: how long you must be off work before payments start. Common choices are 4, 13, 26 or 52 weeks. The choice affects the premium: a longer wait usually costs less. Many people match it to when their employer's sick pay ends, or to how long their savings would last.
  • Own occupation: the policy pays if you cannot do the job you had before you became ill. Stricter definitions pay only if you cannot do other jobs suited to your skills, qualifications and experience ("suited occupation"), or any job at all ("any occupation"). Own occupation is the narrowest test, so it pays in the most situations; any occupation is the hardest to meet.

Example: Jo earns £36,000 in England and takes home about £2,453 a month. Their employer pays only Statutory Sick Pay. In 2026/27 that is £123.25 a week, or 80% of normal weekly earnings if lower, for up to 28 weeks: about £534 a month for Jo. Jo's essentials cost £1,600 a month, so the gap is about £1,066 a month. £6,000 of savings fills that gap for about 5.6 months. Sick pay itself stops after about 6.4 months. Savings cover a few months off work. A longer illness is the loss Jo could not absorb, and the kind that income protection with a 26-week deferred period is designed for.

Statutory Sick Pay is only for employees, so for the self-employed the deferred period is a choice about how long their savings could last.

Critical illness cover

Critical illness cover pays a lump sum if you are diagnosed with one of the serious illnesses listed in the policy. It pays when the diagnosis meets the policy's definition, sometimes only after you have survived a set period such as 14 or 28 days, and does not depend on whether you can still work. The Financial Ombudsman Service says definitions of the main illnesses are generally standardised across the industry, but the number and type of other conditions covered varies.

It differs from income protection in two ways. Income protection covers any illness or injury that stops you working, but pays only while you are off. Critical illness usually pays once, on a listed condition only, though some policies allow more than one claim. Some people hold both; others choose one. It is also sold combined with life cover, in which case it pays out once, on whichever happens first.

Cover for your things and your trips

Contents insurance

Contents insurance pays to replace your belongings after theft, fire, flood or similar damage. This applies to renters and owners alike: the landlord's or freeholder's buildings policy does not cover them. The test is the cost of replacing everything at once. Someone with few belongings, or savings to replace them, may decide to carry the risk.

Travel insurance

GOV.UK says a Global Health Insurance Card (GHIC) or European Health Insurance Card (EHIC) is not an alternative to travel insurance. The cards give access to state healthcare in some countries, but not private treatment or the cost of getting you home. GOV.UK gives the example of a hospital bill of more than £150,000 in the USA for a stomach infection. That is the loss travel insurance is for. GOV.UK says to declare existing conditions and any pending treatment or tests, because failing to declare something may invalidate the policy.

Cover you may already have

Before buying a policy, check these:

  • Death in service. Some employers pay a lump sum if you die while employed. The Civil Service alpha pension scheme, for example, pays the higher of twice final pay or five times the pension built up. It usually stops when you leave the job.
  • Employer sick pay. Your contract or staff handbook says what your employer pays above Statutory Sick Pay and for how long. Some employers also have group income protection, which may overlap with a personal policy.
  • Packaged bank accounts. These charge a monthly fee for a bundle of extras, which can include insurance. The bank must check whether you are eligible for each insurance policy in the package and tell you. One type of complaint the Financial Ombudsman lists comes from people who already had some of the features elsewhere.
  • Home insurance add-ons. Contents policies can include belongings away from home, accidental damage or legal expenses. Check before paying separately for gadget insurance or legal cover, and before buying a travel policy for baggage your contents policy already covers.
  • A mortgage-linked policy. A life or critical illness policy taken out with an earlier mortgage may still be running.

Getting a claim paid

  • Answer every question fully. On critical illness cover, the Financial Ombudsman Service says many of the cases it sees involve an insurer alleging non-disclosure: a detail, such as medical history, left out of the application.
  • Read the definitions. For income protection and critical illness, the wording decides the claim, not the policy name.
  • If the insurer fails. The Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) covers 100% of claims on life, critical illness, income protection and third party motor insurance if a UK insurer regulated by the Prudential Regulation Authority fails, and 90% of most others such as home, travel and pet, with no upper limit. The FSCS guide explains more.
  • If a claim is refused. Complain to the insurer first. If it does not resolve it, the Financial Ombudsman Service is free and covers the whole UK.

When to get help

Protection policies are often bought without advice. Comparing definitions, deferred periods and trusts across insurers is where a protection adviser or broker can help, and a solicitor for trusts with inheritance tax in mind. Our guide to whether you need a financial adviser covers how advisers are paid and how to check they are FCA-authorised. This guide is general information, not advice on your situation. Try our free household bills checklist to keep insurance renewals next to the other household bills.

Work it out

Sources

Information, not advice. Save Sterling publishes general information and calculators, not financial advice or personal recommendations. We are not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Tax rules depend on your circumstances and can change. Save Sterling has the same owner as Earn Sterling, which earns commission from some of what it lists, and Student Sterling, which may earn commission. Last reviewed . How we write and check guides

Get one money-saving bill tip a week

Get one money-saving bill tip a week. Optional, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

We will store your email address and the page you signed up from to send that weekly tip. You can unsubscribe at any time. The address is stored in Cloudflare. Read our privacy notice.