ISA, Lifetime ISA or pension: which comes first?
Short answer, as of
A common order is: enough into a workplace pension to get the full employer contribution, then a pension for higher-rate taxpayers or a Lifetime ISA for basic-rate taxpayers who can open one (under 40), then an ISA. It flips if you may need the money before your late fifties, want a first home, or expect higher-rate tax in retirement.
This is general information, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any investment. The value of investments can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you put in. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future returns. Any fund, platform or provider named is an example only, and none of them pays us. If you are unsure what is right for you, speak to an FCA-authorised financial adviser.
The three side by side
All three are wrappers: accounts that shelter whatever is inside from tax. The same cash or funds can sit in any of them. What differs is the tax on the way in and out, when you can reach the money, and whether anyone else pays in.
| Rule | ISA | Lifetime ISA | Pension |
|---|---|---|---|
| Going in | Nothing added | 25% government bonus | Tax relief at your income tax rate, plus anything your employer pays |
| Growth | Tax-free | Tax-free | Tax-free |
| Coming out | Tax-free | Tax-free at 60 or for a first home. Otherwise a 25% charge | 25% tax-free, the rest taxed as income |
| Earliest access | Any time | 60, or a first home | 55, rising to 57 on 6 April 2028 |
| Yearly limit | £20,000 across all your ISAs | £4,000, inside the ISA limit. Open at 18 to 39, pay in until 50 | Tax relief on what you pay in, up to your earnings for the year. £60,000 allowance, employer money included |
| On death | Counts for inheritance tax. A spouse or civil partner gets a matching extra ISA allowance | Counts for inheritance tax. Ends on death, with no withdrawal charge | Usually outside inheritance tax now. Most unused funds count for deaths from 6 April 2027. Heirs pay income tax if you die at 75 or over |
"ISA" here means an ordinary cash or stocks and shares ISA. The figures are for 2026/27. The rules are the same in all four nations, except that Scotland's income tax rates change what pension tax relief is worth and the tax on pension income.
If the money is invested, its value can fall as well as rise and you may get back less than you paid in, whichever wrapper holds it. Past performance is not a reliable guide to the future, and money needed within about five years is generally not money to invest.
What only a pension gets
Money from your employer. Under automatic enrolment an employer must pay in at least 3% of your qualifying earnings (pay between £6,240 and £50,270 a year) while you pay in too. Some pay more, or match extra contributions up to a ceiling. None of it can go into an ISA or a Lifetime ISA.
Tax relief at your marginal rate. Contributions get income tax relief at the rate you pay on the top slice of your income: 20%, 40% or 45% in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, where the 40% rate starts at £50,270, and 19% to 48% in Scotland. Where a workplace scheme takes contributions from pay before tax, the full relief is automatic. In a relief at source scheme the provider claims the 20% basic rate for you, and anyone paying more has to claim the rest from HMRC.
National Insurance, under salary sacrifice. In a salary sacrifice scheme you agree to lower pay and your employer pays the difference into your pension. No National Insurance is charged on it, which saves 8% on pay up to £50,270 and 2% above. The employer saves 15% too. In research for HMRC published in 2025, some employers said they add that saving to the pension and most said they do not. Lower pay can reduce statutory pay and some earnings-related benefits. From 6 April 2029, National Insurance will be due on sacrificed contributions above £2,000 a year.
What a pension costs
It is locked. The money cannot normally be taken before the normal minimum pension age: 55 today, 57 from 6 April 2028. Ill health is the main exception. That minimum is set by law, and the rise to 57 shows it can move after you have paid in. A scheme's own rules can set a later age.
It is taxed on the way out. Usually 25% can be taken tax-free, up to £268,275 over a lifetime. The rest is taxed as income in the year you take it, on top of everything else you receive. A full new state pension is about £12,548 a year, nearly all of the £12,570 personal allowance, the income you can receive before tax is due. So for someone who gets one, almost none of the taxable part is covered by the allowance.
Warning: A firm that offers to get money out of a pension before 55 is almost certainly running a scam, the FCA says. Money released that way can be an unauthorised payment, which HMRC taxes heavily even if the money has already been spent.
What £100 of take-home pay becomes
The fair comparison starts from take-home pay, because that is what you give up. An ISA or a Lifetime ISA is paid from it pound for pound. A pension contribution costs less than its face value.
Example: Asha earns £35,000 in England and pays basic-rate tax (the sums are the same in Wales and Northern Ireland). Paying £1,000 into a pension lowers her take-home pay by £800, because £200 of it is tax relief. So £100 of take-home pay puts 100 × 1,000 ÷ 800 = £125 into the pension. Under salary sacrifice she also saves £80 of National Insurance, the cost falls to £720, and £100 buys £138.89.
Ben earns £70,000 and pays higher-rate tax. With all his relief claimed, the same £1,000 costs him £600, or £580 under salary sacrifice, so his £100 buys £166.67 or £172.41.
A Lifetime ISA turns the same £100 into £125 for either of them, and an ISA leaves it at £100. So going in, the Lifetime ISA bonus and basic-rate relief are the same size: 25% added to what you pay is 20% of the total.
The pension is then taxed coming out and the other two are not. The table shows what comes back before any growth, with 25% of the pension tax-free and the rest taxed at 20% (basic rate) or 40% (higher rate).
| What £100 becomes | Basic rate now and later | Higher rate now, basic later | Higher rate now and later |
|---|---|---|---|
| ISA | £100 | £100 | £100 |
| Lifetime ISA | £125 | £125 | £125 |
| Pension | £106.25 | £141.67 | £116.67 |
| Pension, salary sacrifice | £118.06 | £146.55 | £120.69 |
Growth does not change the order: with the same investments and charges, every figure in a column is multiplied by the same amount.
Where the answer flips:
- Basic-rate taxpayer, no extra employer money. The Lifetime ISA returns £125 against the pension's £106.25. Salary sacrifice narrows the gap. An employer adding its whole National Insurance saving reverses it: £159.72 in, £135.76 out.
- Salary sacrifice with a student loan. Sacrificed pay also escapes loan repayments, which are 9% of pay over the threshold on Plan 1, 2, 4 and 5 loans. With a Plan 2 loan, Asha's £1,000 through salary sacrifice costs £630, so £100 puts £158.73 in and returns £134.92. The £90 not repaid is a saving only if the loan is written off before it would have been cleared. Otherwise it is repaid later, with interest.
- Any employer match. A pound-for-pound match turns Asha's £100 into £250 in the pension and £212.50 after tax, ahead of everything else.
- Higher-rate taxpayer. The pension leads unless retirement income is also taxed at 40%. Then the Lifetime ISA edges ahead, on up to £4,000 a year, and the pension still beats the ISA.
- Basic rate now, higher rate in retirement. The pension returns £87.50, less than the ISA. A large salary-linked pension or a very large pot can cause this.
- No tax in retirement. Pension income inside the personal allowance, for example before the state pension starts, comes out untaxed: £125, level with the Lifetime ISA.
In Scotland the pension figures differ: £126.58 at £35,000, where the rate is 21%, and £172.41 at £70,000, where it is 42%. Between £43,662 and £50,270 a Scottish taxpayer pays 42% tax and 8% National Insurance, so under salary sacrifice £100 puts £200 into a pension. Scottish rates apply on the way out too.
The £100,000 and Child Benefit thresholds
A pension contribution lowers your adjusted net income, the measure of income used for the thresholds below. Paying into an ISA or a Lifetime ISA does not.
- Between £100,000 and £125,140 the personal allowance is withdrawn by £1 for every £2 of income, the 60% tax trap. Relief on a pension contribution is effectively 60%, or 67.5% in Scotland. £100 of take-home pay puts £250 into a pension, or £263.16 under salary sacrifice. Tax-Free Childcare, and funded childcare hours for working parents in England, stop when either parent's adjusted net income goes over £100,000.
- Between £60,000 and £80,000 with children, the High Income Child Benefit Charge takes back 1% of Child Benefit for every £200 of income over £60,000. It is tested on the higher earner's own income, not the household's. If Ben has two children, £1,000 into a pension saves £400 of income tax and cuts the charge by £119, so his £100 puts £207.90 in.
What an ISA gives: access
Money in an ISA can be taken out at any time, for any reason, with no tax to pay, though a fixed-term cash ISA may set its own penalty. Paying it back in uses up that year's allowance, unless the ISA is a flexible one. Anyone who plans to stop work before the minimum pension age needs money outside a pension to live on until then.
ISA withdrawals are not income. They do not use up the personal allowance or push pension income into a higher band, so holding both gives more control over tax in retirement.
What a Lifetime ISA adds, and its catch
The bonus matches basic-rate relief going in and is not taxed coming out. For a basic-rate taxpayer with no more employer money on offer, that is usually a better result on tax alone, on up to £4,000 a year. The conditions are tight:
- It must be opened between 18 and 39, takes payments until 50, and for retirement stays shut until 60.
- Any other withdrawal, apart from a first home or terminal illness, is charged 25% of the amount taken. That is more than the bonus: £1,000 paid in becomes £1,250, the charge is £312.50 and £937.50 comes back, a loss of 6.25% of your own money.
- A first home must cost £450,000 or less, and be bought with a mortgage at least 12 months after your first payment. Above that price the charge has been 20% since 29 October 2026, which returns the £1,000 paid in without the bonus, growth aside. GOV.UK lists every condition for Lifetime ISA withdrawals.
At Budget 2026 the government said a First Time Buyer ISA, with a bonus paid towards a first home, will replace the Lifetime ISA for new savers from April 2029, with existing holders able to carry on under the current rules. That is not yet law.
Common patterns
The money plan puts the employer contribution early, straight after a starter cash buffer, and other long-term saving after expensive debt and an emergency fund. Within that, these patterns are common:
- Many people first pay in whatever earns the full employer contribution.
- Many basic-rate taxpayers young enough to open a Lifetime ISA then use one, for a first home or for retirement.
- Many higher-rate taxpayers put the next money into the pension instead, more so near the thresholds above.
- Many people use an ISA for anything they may want before their late fifties, and keep some long-term money there too so that not everything is locked or taxable.
These are patterns, not instructions. Which one fits turns on four things: your tax rate now, your likely rate in retirement, when you will need the money, and what your employer adds. The ISA, Lifetime ISA or pension calculator runs the sums with your own numbers.
When the pattern breaks
- Money that may be needed before your late fifties. A pension cannot normally pay it out and a Lifetime ISA charges 25% of the withdrawal. Of the three, only an ISA returns it without a charge.
- A first home. The Lifetime ISA bonus is the only boost here that can be spent on one. A deposit needed within about five years is generally held as cash, which a Lifetime ISA can hold.
- Higher-rate tax in retirement. The pension's lead shrinks or reverses, as the table above shows.
- Universal Credit. Money in an ISA or a Lifetime ISA counts as savings, which can reduce or end an award. A pension that has not been taken is not counted.
- A defined benefit pension, which pays an income based on salary and length of service. The sums here are for defined contribution pensions, where a pot is built from what is paid in.
Tax rules change, and how they apply depends on your circumstances. MoneyHelper gives free guidance on retirement saving options, and its Pension Wise service offers free appointments from age 50 to people with a defined contribution pension. If the sums are large, or a defined benefit pension is involved, an FCA-authorised adviser can advise on your situation.
Work it out
ISA, LISA or pension calculator
The same money in an ISA, a Lifetime ISA and a pension, compared.
CalculatorPension contribution calculator
What a change in your pension contribution does to your take-home pay.
CalculatorMarginal tax rate calculator
What you keep of your next pound, and where the tax traps are.
Sources
- GOV.UK: Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs), how ISAs work
- GOV.UK: Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs), withdrawing your money
- GOV.UK: Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs), if you die
- GOV.UK: Inheriting an ISA from your spouse or civil partner
- GOV.UK: Lifetime ISA
- GOV.UK: Who can open a Lifetime ISA
- GOV.UK: Withdrawing money from your Lifetime ISA
- HMRC: Reduced Lifetime ISA withdrawal charge for properties over the price cap, from 29 October 2026
- HMRC: Budget 2026 overview of tax legislation and rates (First Time Buyer ISA from April 2029)
- GOV.UK: Tax relief on your private pension contributions
- GOV.UK: Pension annual allowance
- GOV.UK: Workplace pensions, what you, your employer and the government pay
- HMRC: Salary sacrifice for employers
- HMRC: Rates and thresholds for employers 2026 to 2027 (National Insurance)
- HMRC: Changes to salary sacrifice for pensions from April 2029
- HMRC research: Employers' attitudes and behaviours towards salary sacrifice for pensions (27 May 2025)
- HMRC Pensions Tax Manual PTM062100: pension age, including the normal minimum pension age and ill health
- HMRC Pensions Tax Manual PTM121000: investments, essential principles (tax exemptions)
- GOV.UK: Tax when you get a pension, what is tax-free
- GOV.UK: Tax when you get a pension
- GOV.UK: The new State Pension, what you'll get
- GOV.UK: Tax on a private pension you inherit
- HMRC: Inheritance Tax on unused pension funds and death benefits, from 6 April 2027
- GOV.UK: Early retirement, your pension and benefits: personal and workplace pensions
- FCA: Pension scams
- GOV.UK: Types of private pensions
- GOV.UK: Plan your retirement income, get help (MoneyHelper and Pension Wise)
- HMRC: Personal Allowances, adjusted net income
- GOV.UK: Income Tax rates and Personal Allowances
- GOV.UK: Income Tax in Scotland
- GOV.UK: High Income Child Benefit Charge
- GOV.UK: Tax-Free Childcare, check if you're eligible
- GOV.UK: Free Childcare for Working Parents (England)
- GOV.UK: Free Childcare for Working Parents, check if you're eligible
- GOV.UK: Repaying your student loan, what you pay
- HMRC: Special rules for student loans (deductions use the same pay as employer's National Insurance)
- GOV.UK: Universal Credit, money, savings and investments
- Universal Credit Regulations 2013, Schedule 10: capital to be disregarded (pension rights, paragraph 10)
Information, not advice. Save Sterling publishes general information and calculators, not financial advice or personal recommendations. We are not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Tax rules depend on your circumstances and can change. Save Sterling has the same owner as Earn Sterling, which earns commission from some of what it lists, and Student Sterling, which may earn commission. Last reviewed . How we write and check guides