ISA, LISA or pension calculator

All three grow free of tax. They differ in what is added on the way in, what is taken on the way out and when you can reach the money. This puts the same slice of take-home pay through each.

For one year, after tax. The comparison follows this one year's money.
A year. It sets your tax relief.
Scotland has its own income tax bands.
Your payslip or scheme booklet says which. If you are not sure, salary sacrifice and net pay both take the contribution before income tax.
A quarter is usually tax-free. This is the rate on the rest. It depends on your total income in the year you take it.
Employer match, student loans and growth
Enter 100 if your employer adds £1 for every £1. Leave at 0 if you already get the full match.
Student loans you are repayingTick each plan you have. Your payslip or the Student Loans Company can tell you which.
Only matters from age 40: one opened before then can be paid into until age 50.
Before charges. An assumption, not a forecast. The same rate is used for all three.
As a share of the pot. The same for all three.
Reset

What £2,400 of take-home pay might come to at age 60

£9,200 to £11,499

After 30 years at 5% growth a year before charges: £9,200 from an ISA, £11,499 from a Lifetime ISA, and £10,861 from a pension after tax. These are estimates, not forecasts. The table shows where the differences come from.

The same take-home pay, three ways
ISALifetime ISAPension
Take-home pay given up£2,400£2,400£2,400
Added by tax relief, National Insurance saved or bonus£0£600£933
Added by your employer£0£0£0
Value at age 60£9,200£11,499£12,777
Tax or charge on the way out£0£0£1,917
What you might get at age 60£9,200£11,499£10,861
Earliest accessAny ageAge 60, or sooner for a first homeAge 57

Tax in retirement changes the pension figure

The pension, at different tax rates when the money is taken
Tax rate on the taxable partWhat you might get
No tax£12,777
20% (basic rate)£10,861
40% (higher rate)£8,944

If growth is lower

What you might get at age 60, at two growth rates
Growth a year before chargesISALifetime ISAPension
5%£9,200£11,499£10,861
3%£5,167£6,458£6,099

Pension: £2,400 of take-home pay is £3,333 going into the pension, because of tax relief and the National Insurance saved by salary sacrifice. Up to 25% of the pot can usually be taken tax-free, within a lump sum allowance of £268,275, and the rest is taxed as income, here at the rate you chose.

From 6 April 2029, salary sacrifice pension contributions above £2,000 a year are due to become liable to National Insurance. That would make the pension figure smaller for money saved from then on.

Lifetime ISA: the government adds 25% to the first £4,000 paid in each year. Taking money out before age 60 costs 25% of the amount withdrawn, unless it goes towards a first home or the saver is terminally ill with less than 12 months to live. A 25% charge takes back the bonus and 6.25% of what you paid in and its growth.

A First Time Buyer ISA has been announced to replace the Lifetime ISA for new savers, with a launch planned for April 2029. Existing Lifetime ISA holders are due to be able to carry on under the current rules. The Lifetime ISA column uses the rules as they are in 2026/27.

The growth rate is an assumption, applied in the same way to all three. Investments can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you put in.

This estimate assumes:

  • One year's saving of £2,400 from take-home pay, left for 30 years
  • England, Wales and Northern Ireland income tax rates for 2026/27, on a salary of £35,000
  • Pension by salary sacrifice: taken before income tax, National Insurance and student loan
  • No extra contribution from your employer
  • Growth of 5% a year before charges of 0.4% a year, the same in each, with a lower case of 3%
  • Pension withdrawals: 25% tax-free up to £268,275, the rest taxed at 20%
  • Lifetime ISA: taken at 60 or later, so no charge
  • Minimum pension age of 55, or 57 from 6 April 2028, worked out by calendar year
  • All amounts are in future pounds, with no adjustment for inflation
  • Left out: the State Pension and other income, tax-free cash already taken from other pensions, any annual allowance charge, inheritance and means-tested benefits
  • Tax rules staying as they are in 2026/27

An estimate. This is an estimate, not advice, a forecast or a quote. It uses 2026/27 tax-year figures, the assumptions shown and only what you entered, so your real figures can differ. Growth rates are assumptions, not predictions: investments can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you put in.

With JavaScript on, the sums run in your browser: what you type is not stored and is not sent to us. Privacy notice

How it works

The calculator takes one amount of take-home pay and follows it through each wrapper.

  • ISA. The money goes in as it is. It grows free of tax and comes out free of tax, at any age.
  • Lifetime ISA. The government adds 25% to the first £4,000 paid in each year. It comes out free of tax from age 60, or sooner towards a first home costing up to £450,000. You must be 18 or over to open one, make the first payment before age 40, and can pay in until age 50. Anything above £4,000 is shown going into an ordinary ISA.
  • Pension. The calculator finds the contribution that would take the same amount off your take-home pay. Because of tax relief that is a larger sum, and any employer match is added to it. On the way out, a quarter is usually tax-free and the rest is taxed as income, at the rate you choose.

Each pot is then grown at the same assumed rate, less charges, until the age you would take the money. A second table repeats the result at a growth rate 2 percentage points lower.

Example: For a basic-rate taxpayer giving up £800 of take-home pay through a net pay scheme, £1,000 goes into the pension, against £1,000 in a Lifetime ISA with its bonus. They start level. The pension is then taxed on three quarters of what comes out, and the Lifetime ISA is not. For a higher-rate taxpayer the same £800 becomes £1,333 in the pension.

With the figures the page opens with (£2,400 of take-home pay, a £35,000 salary taxed at England, Wales and Northern Ireland rates, salary sacrifice, age 30 to 60, 5% growth and 0.4% charges, basic-rate tax on withdrawal), £3,333 goes into the pension and the estimates at 60 are £9,200 from the ISA, £11,499 from the Lifetime ISA and £10,861 from the pension after £1,917 of tax.

What the answer turns on

  • Your tax rate now against your tax rate later. Relief at a higher rate on the way in and tax at a lower rate on the way out is what gives the pension the larger figure for many higher-rate taxpayers. For a basic-rate taxpayer who pays basic-rate tax in retirement, with no employer money and no National Insurance saving, the Lifetime ISA's bonus gives the larger figure. The table of retirement tax rates shows how far the pension result moves.
  • Employer money. A pound from an employer that you would not otherwise get is not matched by either ISA. If part of an employer match is unclaimed, enter it.
  • Salary sacrifice. It saves National Insurance as well as income tax, and lowers student loan repayments, which leaves more of the loan to repay later. From 6 April 2029, salary sacrifice pension contributions above £2,000 a year are due to become liable to National Insurance.
  • When you need the money. An ISA can be reached at any time. A Lifetime ISA charges 25% of anything withdrawn before age 60 for another purpose, which takes back the bonus and 6.25% of your own money. For a first home costing more than £450,000 the charge is 20%. A pension cannot usually be touched before age 55, rising to 57 from 6 April 2028.

A calculator can do the sums. It cannot weigh how much access matters to you, how secure your job is or what the rules will be in thirty years, and it does not try to.

Limits each year

  • ISAs: £20,000 a year across all your ISAs, of which up to £4,000 can go into a Lifetime ISA.
  • Pensions: tax relief on contributions up to your earnings, within an annual allowance of £60,000 that is lower for very high incomes.

What it leaves out

  • Later years. It follows one year's money. Saving every year builds larger pots, and the limits apply afresh each tax year.
  • The State Pension and any other income, which affect the tax you pay in retirement. One flat rate is applied to the taxable part of the pension. In practice it can span more than one band, and Scotland has its own rates on pension income.
  • Other pensions. The tax-free quarter is capped at the lump sum allowance of £268,275. The calculator applies the cap to this pot alone and ignores tax-free cash taken from other pensions.
  • The annual allowance. The calculator warns when the contribution is above £60,000 but does not work out the charge, the lower allowance for very high incomes or the one that applies after flexibly taking a pension.
  • Inflation. Results are in future pounds, which will buy less than pounds today.
  • Different charges or investments in each. The same growth and charges are used for all three.
  • What happens on death. Pensions and ISAs are treated differently, and most unused pension funds count towards inheritance tax for deaths from 6 April 2027.
  • Means-tested benefits, where savings in an ISA count as capital and money left untouched in a pension is not counted until Pension Credit qualifying age.
  • Buying a first home, which is the other use of a Lifetime ISA. See the Lifetime ISA guide.
  • Changes to the rules. Tax rates, allowances and access ages are taken as they are in 2026/27, and can change before the money is taken. A First Time Buyer ISA has been announced to replace the Lifetime ISA for new savers, with a launch planned for April 2029. Details are in the ISAs guide.

The guide to choosing between them sets out the reasoning in full.

This is general information, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any investment. The value of investments can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you put in. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future returns. Any fund, platform or provider named is an example only, and none of them pays us. If you are unsure what is right for you, speak to an FCA-authorised financial adviser.

Sources

2026/27 tax-year figures Last reviewed

Guides that go with this

Related calculators

Get one money-saving bill tip a week

Get one money-saving bill tip a week. Optional, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

We will store your email address and the page you signed up from to send that weekly tip. You can unsubscribe at any time. The address is stored in Cloudflare. Read our privacy notice.