Overpay the mortgage or invest? What it turns on
Short answer, as of
Overpaying saves interest at your mortgage rate, tax-free and certain while that rate lasts. Cash beats it only by paying more after tax. Shares have returned more over long periods but can lose money over shorter ones, and a pension adds tax relief at the price of access. It turns on your rate, tax band, timescale and need for access.
Three kinds of return
The money can go to three places, and they do not pay in the same way.
- Overpaying the mortgage. Each pound overpaid stops being charged interest at your mortgage rate. The saving is certain and, because it is a cost avoided and not income, there is no tax on it. It runs at whatever your rate is at the time: known during a fixed rate, unknown after it.
- Saving in cash. A savings account pays a stated rate, less any tax on the interest, and the money stays within reach.
- Investing. Shares and funds have no stated return. The value of investments can fall as well as rise, you may get back less than you put in, and past performance is not a reliable guide to the future.
So overpaying against cash is arithmetic. Overpaying against investing sets a certain return against an uncertain one, and no sum settles that. This guide assumes a repayment mortgage on your own home.
The savings rate that matches your mortgage
A savings account matches an overpayment when its rate after tax equals the mortgage rate:
Savings rate needed = mortgage rate ÷ (1 − tax rate on the interest)
The tax rate is nil in a cash ISA, and nil on interest within your allowances. In 2026/27 the personal savings allowance covers £1,000 of interest a year for basic-rate taxpayers and £500 for higher-rate taxpayers. Additional-rate taxpayers get none. People whose other income is under £17,570 can also have up to £5,000 of interest taxed at 0%.
Beyond those, interest is taxed at 20%, 40% or 45%. Rates of 24%, 44% and 49% have been announced from 6 April 2027 and, as of November 2026, are not yet law. Scotland uses the same UK rates and bands for savings interest, and the figures in Wales and Northern Ireland are the same as in England.
One refinement: a mortgage rate is charged a slice at a time, monthly or daily, so 4.5% adds up to about 4.59% over a year. That is the figure to set against a savings account's AER, the yearly rate accounts quote. To match a mortgage at 4.5%:
| Tax on the interest | Rate needed in 2026/27 | From 6 April 2027, if enacted |
|---|---|---|
| None: an ISA, or within your allowances | 4.59% | 4.59% |
| Basic rate | 5.74% | 6.04% |
| Higher rate | 7.66% | 8.2% |
| Additional rate | 8.35% | 9.01% |
At 4.5% interest, the basic-rate allowance covers about £22,000 of savings and the higher-rate allowance about £11,000, so smaller pots are often in the top row.
Example: Ben earns £60,000 and his existing savings already use up his £500 allowance. His mortgage rate is 4.5%. Overpaying £10,000 saves him £459 of interest over the next year. In a savings account paying 5%, a rate made up for the sum, it earns £500, of which £200 goes in tax and £300 is kept. In a cash ISA at the same rate he keeps all £500.
Banks generally charge borrowers more than they pay savers, but a mortgage fixed at a low rate some years ago can cost less than an ordinary savings account pays. The comparison changes when a fixed rate ends or savings rates move.
Investing: a higher return hoped for, not known
Over long periods shares have returned more than cash. In all 21 countries with unbroken records from 1900 to 2025, shares were the best-performing asset class, ahead of government bonds and short-term government bills (the closest thing to cash in the data). The source is the UBS Global Investment Returns Yearbook 2026, by Elroy Dimson, Paul Marsh and Mike Staunton. Those are returns on market indices, so an investor's charges and any tax come off them.
The same study notes that since 1900 shares and bonds have on several occasions lost more than 70% of their value after inflation. Over any shorter stretch the result can be a loss. That is why the Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) talks of investing for at least five years, and why money needed sooner is generally not money to invest.
Two things narrow the gap between that history and your mortgage:
- The hurdle is higher than cash. A mortgage usually costs more than cash earns, so beating cash is not the same as beating the mortgage.
- Charges and tax come off. In a stocks and shares ISA there is no tax on income or gains, and up to £20,000 a year can go in. Elsewhere, dividends and gains above the yearly allowances are taxed: see investing outside an ISA.
A worked comparison
Example: Asha owes £200,000 on a repayment mortgage at 4.5% with 25 years left. Her payment is £1,111.66 a month and she has £200 a month spare. If she overpays it, after 10 years she owes £30,240 less than she otherwise would. Kept up, the overpayment clears the mortgage 6 years and 1 month early and saves £36,280 of interest. This assumes her rate never changes and that her lender shortens the term and leaves the monthly payment alone.
If she puts the £200 a month into a stocks and shares ISA instead, the outcome depends on growth nobody knows in advance. Three assumptions, each after charges:
| £200 a month for 10 years | Worth | Against overpaying |
|---|---|---|
| Overpaid at 4.5% | £30,240 less owed | Certain if the rate holds |
| Invested, growing 6% a year | £32,495 | £2,255 ahead |
| Invested, growing 4% a year | £29,339 | £900 behind |
| Invested, growing 2% a year | £26,519 | £3,720 behind |
The break-even is growth of 4.59% a year after charges: the mortgage rate again.
These are smooth paths, and markets are not smooth. A 20% fall at the end of the tenth year would leave the 6% pot at £25,996. The mortgage rate will not hold still either: each new deal resets the hurdle. All these amounts are in the pounds of 10 years' time. If prices rose 2% a year, each would buy about 18% less than today, which moves every row alike.
The mortgage overpayment calculator runs this comparison on your own figures.
A pension changes the sum
A pension is investing with two additions and one restriction.
- Tax relief. For a basic-rate taxpayer, £100 of take-home pay becomes £125 in a pension. For a higher-rate taxpayer it becomes about £167 once any extra relief is claimed. In Scotland, where relief follows the Scottish rates, the figures are £127 at the 21% rate and £172 at 42%. Pension tax relief explains how it reaches you.
- Employer money. Under automatic enrolment an employer must pay in at least 3% of qualifying earnings, and some pay more if you do. Where part of a match is unused, a pension contribution brings in pay that an overpayment cannot: see workplace pensions and the employer match.
- Access. The money cannot normally be taken before age 55, rising to 57 from 6 April 2028. Up to 25% can usually be taken tax-free and the rest is taxed as income. Taxed at 20% on the way out, the £125 above is worth £106 and the £167 is worth £142, before any growth or loss.
The price of the lock falls with age. At 52 it lasts a few years. At 30 it lasts decades, and the rules can change in that time.
Getting the money back
On most mortgages an overpayment is hard to reverse. Getting it back means asking for more borrowing, which the lender must check is affordable and can refuse. The check is on income and outgoings, so a request made after a drop in income, when the money is most likely to be wanted, is harder to pass.
Some mortgages are more flexible. The illustration that FCA rules require a lender to give you has a "flexible features" section. It says whether money overpaid can be borrowed back, whether payment holidays are allowed, and whether a linked savings account comes with the mortgage.
Cash savings can be withdrawn, and so can investments in an ISA, though they may be worth less on the day. This is why the usual order puts an emergency fund before both overpaying and investing. The FCA's guidance for new investors also starts with emergency savings that can be reached at once.
Early repayment charges and the yearly allowance
During a fixed rate, lenders usually cap overpayments and make an early repayment charge (ERC) on anything above the cap. The FCA said in May 2025 that most lenders allow between 10% and 20% of the outstanding balance to be overpaid each year of a fixed rate without a charge.
In the FCA's own example of a five-year fixed rate the charge falls from 5% in the first year to 1% in the last. FCA rules require it to be a reasonable estimate of what early repayment costs the lender. At a mortgage rate of 4.5%, a charge of 3% of the amount repaid cancels about 8 months of the interest saved on the money it applies to.
Your mortgage offer gives the limit and the charge. The yearly mortgage statement shows the charge in pounds and the date it stops applying. Money held in cash during a fixed rate can be paid off the mortgage once that date has passed, which is one way people keep the choice open.
The next remortgage
Loan-to-value (LTV) is the loan as a percentage of the property's value. Lenders price mortgages in LTV bands: the Bank of England's quoted-rate series are for loans of 60%, 75%, 85%, 90% and 95% LTV. Bank of England staff research published in 2018 found that UK rates rise in steps at the band thresholds, with the largest steps above 85% and 90%.
So an overpayment that takes the loan below a threshold before the next remortgage can lower the rate offered on the whole balance, a gain on top of the interest saved. One that leaves the loan in the same band earns the mortgage rate and no more. House prices move LTV too, in either direction.
Owing less has a value of its own
Some of this does not fit in a table. A smaller mortgage means a smaller payment to find at the next deal, whatever rates have done by then, and an earlier end to the payments altogether. Many people value being clear of the debt for its own sake. That value is real, even though no calculator shows it.
So is the value of the alternative. Money in savings or an ISA can be reached and used for something else, and a fund can be spread across thousands of companies. Equity in one home can only be reached by selling or borrowing.
One way to see both sides: keeping the mortgage in order to invest is the same position as borrowing against the home at the mortgage rate to invest. Overpaying is choosing a fixed return from one asset over an uncertain return from many. People comfortable with one description are often uneasy with the other.
What changes the answer
- The mortgage rate. It is the hurdle everything else has to clear. On a low rate fixed for years, even cash may clear it. It changes with each new deal, so the answer can change then too.
- Your tax band. Tax on interest raises the hurdle for cash, as the table shows. For a pension it works the other way: relief at 40% or more is a larger head start than relief at 20%.
- Your time horizon. Money needed within about five years is generally not money to invest, which leaves overpaying against cash. Over decades a fall has longer to be made good, though nothing makes that certain.
- An unused employer match. Where one exists, a contribution brings in employer money on top of tax relief, a gain that overpaying and saving do not offer, with access as the price.
- An emergency fund. Without one, both overpaying and investing put money where it is slow or costly to reach.
It does not have to be all one or the other. Many people split the money, and look again when a fixed rate ends, a pay rise moves them into another tax band, or an employer changes its pension terms.
When to get advice
This guide is general information, not advice on what to do with your money. The mix that suits a household depends on things no guide can see: how secure its income is, what else it owes and owns, and how it would cope with a fall in the value of investments. Tax depends on personal circumstances, and the rules can change.
For pensions, MoneyHelper gives free, impartial information, and people aged 50 or over with a defined contribution pension can book a free Pension Wise appointment. If the sums are large, an FCA-authorised financial adviser can advise on your situation. Do you need a financial adviser? explains what they do and what they charge.
Work it out
Mortgage overpayment calculator
The interest and years an overpayment saves, against saving or investing.
CalculatorSavings interest tax calculator
Whether your savings interest is taxed, and how much.
CalculatorPension contribution calculator
What a change in your pension contribution does to your take-home pay.
Sources
- FCA Handbook: Mortgages and Home Finance Conduct of Business sourcebook (MCOB 12.3 early repayment charges, 5A the mortgage illustration, 7.5 yearly statements, 11.6 affordability)
- FCA: CP25/11, Mortgage Rule Review (May 2025), paragraph 3.30 on overpayment allowances
- GOV.UK: Tax on savings interest – how much is tax-free
- GOV.UK: Budget 2026, Annex A – rates and allowances for 2026 to 2027 and 2027 to 2028
- GOV.UK: Income Tax in Scotland
- GOV.UK: Individual Savings Accounts – how ISAs work
- GOV.UK: Tax on your private pension contributions – tax relief
- GOV.UK: Workplace pensions – what you, your employer and the government pay
- HMRC Pensions Tax Manual PTM062100: normal minimum pension age
- GOV.UK: Personal pensions – how you can take your pension
- GOV.UK: Personal pensions – get help (MoneyHelper and Pension Wise)
- FCA InvestSmart: Risk and returns
- FCA InvestSmart: The golden rules of investing
- Bank of England: Further details about quoted household interest rates data
- Bank of England Staff Working Paper No. 713: Down payment and mortgage rates (February 2018)
- UBS Global Investment Returns Yearbook 2026, public summary edition (Dimson, Marsh and Staunton; returns from 1900 to 2025)
Information, not advice. Save Sterling publishes general information and calculators, not financial advice or personal recommendations. We are not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Tax rules depend on your circumstances and can change. Save Sterling has the same owner as Earn Sterling, which earns commission from some of what it lists, and Student Sterling, which may earn commission. Last reviewed . How we write and check guides