Paying off debt: which order costs least

Short answer, as of

Debts such as rent, a mortgage, council tax and energy are treated as priorities because of what happens if they go unpaid. Among the rest, once every minimum is paid, spare money sent to the highest interest rate costs the least interest. Sending it to the smallest balance clears individual debts sooner and usually costs more.

Priority debts work differently

Free debt advisers split debts into two groups, and interest rate is not what separates them. A priority debt is one where not paying has serious consequences. The Citizens Advice list for England includes these. A phone or internet bill joins the list for someone who depends on the service.

DebtWhat can happen if it is not paid
Rent, a mortgage or a loan secured on a homeEviction or repossession, after a court order
Council taxCourt action, money taken from wages or benefits, bailiffs
Gas and electricityDisconnection
Court fines, TV licenceFurther court action. Prison is possible for someone who can pay and refuses
Income tax, National Insurance, VATHMRC can take money from wages, or take and sell belongings. It can also go to court
Child maintenanceMoney taken from wages or bank accounts, loss of a driving licence or passport
Hire purchase, where the goods are essentialThe goods, often a car, can be taken back

Credit cards, store cards, catalogues, overdrafts, unsecured loans and payday loans are non-priority debts. Not paying them still matters: the lender can add charges, mark your credit file and take you to court. But nobody loses their home or their heating as the first step.

This is why a card charging 30% can rank below a council tax bill charging no interest. The methods in the rest of this guide are about non-priority debts, for someone who is up to date with the priority ones.

The lists for Wales, Scotland and Northern Ireland are close to this one, with differences of detail. In England a court can send someone to prison for up to three months for council tax they could pay and refuse to. Wales removed that power from 1 April 2019. In Scotland the council usually gets a summary warrant from the sheriff court and can then take money from earnings or a bank account. Northern Ireland has rates in place of council tax, and nidirect lists them as a priority debt.

The minimum on everything comes first

Each of the methods below assumes every debt gets at least its minimum payment, every month. Paying less than the minimum counts as being behind. The card provider can add a default charge, interest is then charged on that too, the provider can withdraw a 0% deal, and credit files show lenders whether payments were made on time.

Only money left after all the minimums is "spare" in what follows. If there is none, or the minimums cannot all be met, the methods do not apply, and the last section is the relevant one.

Two methods for the spare money

Both methods send all the spare money to one debt. When that debt is gone, its whole payment moves to the next one, so the total paid each month stays the same until everything is cleared.

  • Highest interest rate first, sometimes called the avalanche method. With the same total paid each month, this costs the least interest, because each pound goes where it stops the most interest. National Debtline calls it usually the quickest and cheapest way to repay without further borrowing. The drawback is that the first debt can take a long time to disappear.
  • Smallest balance first, sometimes called the snowball method. Individual debts are cleared sooner, which leaves fewer payments to keep track of and gives an early sign of progress. National Debtline says it may be worth choosing for people who find it hard to stay motivated. It costs more interest unless the smallest debts also happen to carry the highest rates.

Example: Asha owes £9,200: £3,000 on a credit card at 24.9% APR (the yearly cost of borrowing), £1,200 on a loan at 9.9% and £5,000 on a second card at 39.9%. The minimums come to £285 a month and she can pay £450, so £165 is spare. The rates are illustrations.

Highest rate firstSmallest balance first
First debt cleared after1 year and 8 months7 months
Everything cleared after2 years and 4 months2 years and 6 months
Interest paid£2,980£3,884

On these figures, highest rate first costs £904 less. Smallest balance first has one debt gone in 7 months, where the other method takes 1 year and 8 months to clear its first. Paying only the minimums would take 6 years and 3 months and cost £8,687 in interest.

The gap here is wide because the rates are far apart and the smallest debt is the cheapest. When rates are close the two methods cost nearly the same, and when the smallest debts are also the dearest they are the same method. The example keeps each minimum fixed, charges interest monthly, and assumes no new spending, no fees and no rate changes.

Which matters more, the pounds or the early progress, is a personal judgement. The debt payoff calculator runs both on your own figures.

Neither method allows for early repayment charges. Some loans have them, and the loan agreement says so.

How minimum payments keep a balance alive

A credit card minimum is not a fixed amount. FCA rules say that on cards opened since 1 April 2011 it must cover at least that month's interest, fees and charges plus 1% of what is owed. Some cards set theirs higher. The card agreement gives the formula.

Because the minimum is tied to the balance, it falls as the balance falls. Each month's payment is a little smaller than the last, so the debt shrinks more and more slowly.

Example: £3,000 on a card at 24.9% APR, with a minimum of the interest plus 1% of the balance and an assumed floor of £5. The first minimum is £86. Paying only the minimum each month, with no new spending, takes 28 years and 5 months and costs £5,395 in interest. Paying a fixed £86 every month instead takes 4 years and 10 months and costs £1,904.

The second figure needs no extra money in month one. It only needs the payment not to fall. FCA rules require card firms to let an automatic payment be set at any amount at or above the minimum, so a fixed amount is an option on any card.

The FCA calls it persistent debt when, over 18 months, a cardholder has paid more in interest, fees and charges than they have repaid of the balance. The card provider must then contact the cardholder and offer help. It must send a reminder at 27 months if the pattern looks likely to continue, and at 36 months it must set out ways to repay faster. If those are unaffordable it must take steps such as reducing, waiving or cancelling interest, fees and charges.

How a 0% balance transfer works

A balance transfer moves a card debt to a different card that charges 0% on it for a set number of months. During that time every pound paid reduces the debt.

The costs and the ways it goes wrong:

  • The fee. There is usually a one-off fee, a percentage of the amount moved, and it is added to the debt.
  • The end date. Whatever is left when the 0% period ends is charged the card's standard rate, which is often much higher.
  • A missed payment. The provider can withdraw the 0% rate.
  • Acceptance. It is a credit application, so it involves a credit check that is recorded on your file. The longer 0% deals may not be offered to people without a good credit record.
  • New spending. The old card is now empty and still open. Anything spent on either card adds to what is owed, and if the old card fills up again the debt has grown, not moved.

Example: Moving the £3,000 above with a 3% fee makes it £3,090. Clearing that in a 20-month 0% period takes £154.50 a month, and the fee of £90 is the whole cost. The same payment on the original card would mean £763 of interest over 2 years and 1 month. At £100 a month, £1,090 is still owed when the 0% ends. The fee and the period are illustrations: real offers vary and change often.

So a transfer cuts the cost for someone who is accepted, clears most of the balance within the period and does not borrow more. It can leave someone owing more than before if the 0% rate is lost, or if the old card is used again.

How a consolidation loan works

A consolidation loan is one new loan used to pay off several debts in full. What is left is a single monthly payment with a known end date.

Whether it costs less depends on two things: the rate you are offered, which depends on your credit record, and the length of the loan. At the same rate, a longer term gives a lower monthly payment and a higher total.

Example: A loan for Asha's £9,200 at 12% APR over 3 years costs £303 a month and £1,704 in interest. Over 7 years it costs £159 a month and £4,190 in interest. Keeping the three debts and paying £450 a month, highest rate first, costs £2,980. So the shorter loan costs less than that and the longer one costs more, even though its rate is far lower. The rate is an illustration, and the rate offered to any one person may be higher.

Other costs and risks:

  • Fees. nidirect says there are usually extra charges for setting up and repaying the new loan. There may also be a charge for repaying it early, and a loan it replaces may have an early repayment charge of its own.
  • Security. Some consolidation loans are secured on a home. That turns debts that could not cost you the home into one that can.
  • A higher rate. People with a poor credit record may be offered only a high rate or a secured loan.
  • Missing payments. After missed payments the lender could ask for the whole loan to be repaid at once, including interest.
  • The old accounts. If cards and overdrafts stay open and are used again, the result is the loan plus new debt.

National Debtline generally advises against new borrowing for someone who cannot afford their existing debts or has missed payments and had default notices, and says independent advice before borrowing is always a good idea.

Saving while in debt

On interest alone the sums point one way. Card debt usually charges far more than savings earn, so each pound held in savings while the debt remains costs the difference between the two rates.

The argument for a small buffer is about what happens next, not about rates. With nothing set aside, the next car repair or broken boiler goes on the card, or a priority bill is missed. A common middle course is a small buffer first, often about a month of essential spending, then the debt, then the full emergency fund.

The comparison changes for some debts:

  • Debt at 0% costs nothing until the period ends, so savings earning interest are ahead until then, provided the money is there on the end date.
  • A loan with an early repayment charge can cost more to clear early than it saves.
  • Student loans are repaid as a share of income above a threshold, not by balance, and anything left is written off after a set number of years that depends on the plan. The sums are different: see student loans explained.
  • A mortgage is a long-term debt at a lower rate, with its own trade-off: see overpaying a mortgage or investing.

The money plan shows where clearing debt sits among the other steps.

When the sums stop being the point

Everything above assumes the minimums are affordable and the priority bills are paid. If any of these describe your position, the choice of method is no longer the question:

  • The minimum payments cannot all be met.
  • A priority debt is in arrears.
  • Credit is paying for food, rent or bills, or for the payments on other credit.
  • A default notice, a letter about court action or a visit from bailiffs has arrived.
  • The debts are affecting your sleep or your health.

Free debt advice is the next step. It is confidential and it costs nothing. An adviser asks about your income, spending and debts, works out a budget with you, and explains the options that exist for people who cannot pay in full, including formal ones this guide does not cover. The box near the top of this page lists where to find it. Nobody needs to pay a firm for debt advice.

There are also schemes that give time to work things out. In England and Wales, a debt adviser can apply for Breathing Space, which stops creditors adding interest and charges to the debts it covers, contacting you about them or taking enforcement action, for up to 60 days. Payments are still due during it. In Scotland a moratorium, which you or a money adviser can apply for, stops creditors taking action to recover debts for 6 months, though interest and charges can still be added. In Northern Ireland, nidirect points to Advice NI and StepChange for free advice.

Our guide to what to do if you cannot pay your debts covers what happens from there.

Work it out

Sources

Information, not advice. Save Sterling publishes general information and calculators, not financial advice or personal recommendations. We are not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Tax rules depend on your circumstances and can change. Save Sterling has the same owner as Earn Sterling, which earns commission from some of what it lists, and Student Sterling, which may earn commission. Last reviewed . How we write and check guides

Get one money-saving bill tip a week

Get one money-saving bill tip a week. Optional, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

We will store your email address and the page you signed up from to send that weekly tip. You can unsubscribe at any time. The address is stored in Cloudflare. Read our privacy notice.