Index funds explained: how they work and what to compare

Short answer, as of

An index fund buys the companies in a market index instead of paying a manager to pick some, aiming for the index's return less its costs. Trackers differ by index, accumulation or income units, fund or ETF, and charges. Values can fall a long way, for years, so money needed within about five years is generally not money to invest.

This is general information, not a recommendation to buy, sell or hold any investment. The value of investments can fall as well as rise, and you may get back less than you put in. Past performance is not a reliable guide to future returns. Any fund, platform or provider named is an example only, and none of them pays us. If you are unsure what is right for you, speak to an FCA-authorised financial adviser.

What a fund is, and what an index is

A fund pools money from many investors and buys investments with it. You own units in the fund, and their price moves with the value of what it holds.

An index is a list of investments drawn up by published rules, with a weight for each. The FTSE 100, for example, is the 100 largest companies traded on the London Stock Exchange, weighted by market value, so the biggest count for most.

An index fund, also called a tracker or a passive fund, aims to match one index by holding everything in it, or a representative sample, in the same proportions. Nobody decides which companies look promising. An active fund pays a manager to pick investments in an attempt to beat an index.

Either kind can fall in value as well as rise, you may get back less than you put in, and past performance is not a reliable guide to the future.

Tracking against picking

Before costs, all the investors in a market earn the market's return between them, because together they are the market. So investors who pick, taken as a group, earn the market's return less their costs, and a tracker earns it less its own, usually lower, costs.

The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) measured what happened in practice in its Asset Management Market Study. It took funds on sale in the UK from 2003 to 2015 and compared each with its benchmark, the index it is measured against. It found that:

  • Active funds on average beat their benchmarks before charges (funds are only some of the investors who pick), then lagged them by about 0.6 percentage points a year after charges.
  • Trackers lagged after charges by a similar amount, though the FCA warned the two groups were not like for like. On average, neither kind beat its benchmark.
  • Among active share funds sold to the public, there was no clear link between higher charges and better performance before charges, and some evidence that dearer funds did worse after them.
  • Past winners were a poor guide: the research it reviewed showed little sign that they went on beating their benchmark.

How often an active fund comes out ahead depends on the period. The FCA reproduced a count by the index compiler S&P of UK share funds priced in pounds. The proportion lagging their benchmark over one year swung from 22% in 2015 to 86% in the year to June 2016. Over ten years it was 72% to the end of 2015 and 77% to June 2016. The FCA said the figures may understate the lag, because they leave out funds closed or merged after doing badly.

The label does not settle the cost. A cheap tracker that follows its index closely ends up close to the index's return, and a dear one does not. The study found about £6 billion in trackers costing significantly more than average, and about £109 billion in "active" funds that closely followed the market while charging significantly more than trackers.

These are averages for periods that ended about ten years ago, and the FCA found wide variation around them. Some active funds do beat their index after charges. The difficulty is knowing which in advance.

Each choice gives something up. A tracker is not trying to beat its index, and it falls as far as its market falls because nobody is steering. An active fund keeps the chance of doing better, for a higher charge and with the risk of doing worse.

Which index: global or one country

A tracker is only as spread out as its index. Concentration means how much of your money rides on a few companies, one country or one industry. Two indices as examples:

At 30 October 2026Global (MSCI ACWI)UK (FTSE 100)
Companies2,413 in 47 countries100, all traded in London
Largest countryUS, about 65%UK-listed only
Ten largest holdingsabout 24%about 50%
Technology sectorabout 31%about 3%

These are indices, not funds: many funds track each, and other compilers publish their own. The two here classify industries slightly differently.

A global tracker's weights follow market value, so it holds more of whatever has grown and less of whatever has shrunk without anyone making that call.

It is not evenly spread: about 65% of this index is in one country and about a quarter is in ten holdings, so it leans heavily on large US companies. Most of it is priced in other currencies, mainly US dollars, so its value in pounds moves with exchange rates as well as share prices.

A single-country tracker concentrates further: half the FTSE 100 is ten companies. It is less of a bet on the UK economy than it looks, because FTSE Russell calculated that 76% of its companies' revenue came from overseas in 2015 to 2017. Its mix of industries differs too: banks, energy and health care are each more than 12% of the index, and technology under 3%.

Any one country narrows the spread in the same way: a US-only tracker leaves out about a third of the global index by value.

What the choice turns on: a global tracker needs no view on which country will do well, but it takes the world's market weights as they are, US-heavy at present. A single-country tracker ties the result to one market, on the judgement that it will do at least as well as the rest. The country that led over the last ten years may or may not lead over the next ten.

"World" in a fund's name does not always mean everything. The MSCI World index covers 23 developed countries and leaves out emerging markets such as China, India and Taiwan. It was about 73% US at the same date. Neither MSCI index holds smaller companies. A fund's factsheet names the index it tracks.

Accumulation or income units

Many funds come in two versions that hold the same investments:

  • Income units (Inc) pay out the fund's income, such as the dividends on its shares, to you as cash.
  • Accumulation units (Acc) keep that income in the fund and reinvest it, so the unit price rises instead.

Accumulation units suit people building up a pot, because the income is reinvested without any action or dealing charge. Income units suit people who want the income to spend.

In an ISA or a pension the choice has no tax effect. In a general investment account, which is taxable, the two are treated alike: HMRC treats income reinvested in accumulation units as income you received, although no cash arrives. That income is also added to the cost of your units when a gain is worked out, so records matter. The guide to investing outside an ISA covers this.

Fund or ETF

The same index can be tracked by two kinds of product:

  • An ordinary fund, which you will see called a unit trust or an OEIC (open-ended investment company). You deal with the fund's manager at the price set at its next valuation, typically once each working day for funds on platforms, so you do not know the exact price when you place the order.
  • An exchange-traded fund (ETF). Its shares are listed on a stock exchange, and you buy or sell them during the trading day at the market price, as you would a company's shares. That price usually sits close to the value of what the ETF holds, but FCA research found the gap widened sharply in the market stress of March 2020.

Tracking the same index at the same charge, the two should return much the same. The practical differences:

  • Dealing costs. An ETF has a gap between its buying and selling prices, and platforms (the firms you buy and hold investments through) may charge differently for funds and for ETFs. Which is cheaper depends on the platform, the size of your pot and how often you buy. See investment platform fees.
  • How it tracks. A physical ETF holds the shares in its index. A synthetic ETF has a contract with a financial institution that pays it the index's return for a fee, so it also depends on that institution paying.
  • Where it is based. Most ETFs traded in the UK are funds based elsewhere in Europe, the FCA said in December 2023. Claims against an overseas fund's own operator are unlikely to be covered by the Financial Services Compensation Scheme (FSCS) or the Financial Ombudsman Service, and FCA rules require its advertising to say so. The services of a UK-authorised platform or adviser stay within both.

The ongoing charge, and why small differences matter

A fund's ongoing charges figure (OCF) is the yearly cost of running it, as a percentage of your holding. It is taken inside the fund, so you never get a bill: the unit price is a little lower than it would have been.

The OCF is shown in a fund's key investor information document, and is the headline cost in the product summary that is due to replace that document by 8 June 2027. It leaves out the fund's own trading costs and anything your platform charges.

For scale, the FCA reported that in 2020 the average ongoing charge on UK-based funds, weighted by size, was 0.15% for passive funds and 0.89% for active funds. Those averages are several years old: a fund's own document gives its charge.

Example: Priya pays in the equivalent of £200 a month in today's money for 30 years, £72,000 in all. Assume her investments grow by 4% a year above inflation before charges. That is an assumption for the sum, not a forecast, and real markets do not grow evenly. With a 0.15% charge she ends with about £133,000 in today's money. With a 0.9% charge she ends with about £117,000, which is £16,000 less. At 2% growth the figures are about £96,000 and £85,000, a gap of £11,000. A platform charge would reduce all four.

The gap is large because the charge is taken every year from the whole pot, past growth included, not only from what is paid in. Try your own numbers in the compound growth calculator.

Two trackers of the same index should return almost the same before charges. That leaves the charge, and how closely each has kept to the index (its tracking difference), as the main differences.

Where the fund is held is a separate question

The fund is the investment. The account it sits in sets the tax and when you can take money out. Index funds can be held in all three of these, though a workplace pension offers only the funds its provider makes available:

AccountTaxAccess
Stocks and shares ISANone on income or gains. Up to £20,000 a year across your ISAsAny time
PensionTax relief going in. 25% usually tax-free coming out, the rest taxed as incomeFrom age 55, or 57 from 6 April 2028
General investment accountDividends above £500 a year and gains above £3,000 a year can be taxedAny time

The figures are for 2026/27 and apply in all four nations. Pension tax relief depends on your income tax rate, which is different in Scotland. Tax depends on your circumstances, and the rules can change.

The guide to an ISA, a Lifetime ISA or a pension compares the accounts. If you have a workplace pension that builds up a pot, the money in it is already invested, and your pension provider can tell you which funds it is in.

How far it can fall

A share tracker falls as far as its market. Three examples from the indices above, before charges and inflation:

  • The MSCI ACWI fell 58% between 31 October 2007 and 9 March 2009, measured in US dollars. The pound fell from $2.08 to $1.38 between those dates on Bank of England rates, so in pounds the fall was smaller, about 37%.
  • The FTSE 100's deepest fall in the ten years to October 2026 was 34%, with dividends included.
  • The FTSE 100 dropped 31% in the calendar year 2008 and took the following two years to regain it, on FTSE Russell's account.

The sums are lopsided: after a 50% fall, a fund has to double to get back. Nothing says it will do so by the time you need the money. That is why money needed within about five years is generally not money to invest. The FCA's consumer guidance talks of at least five years, and adds that even long-term investors can end up with less than they put in.

A fall is only locked in if you sell, and needing the money at a set time can force a sale after a bad run. The money plan puts an emergency fund in cash ahead of investing for that reason.

The FSCS does not cover falls in value. It can pay up to £85,000 per person, per firm, if an FCA-authorised firm fails and cannot return your money or investments.

Multi-asset funds: shares and bonds mixed for you

A multi-asset fund holds several kinds of investment in one fund, usually shares and bonds, and its manager looks after the mix. Bonds are loans to governments and companies that can be bought and sold. They are included because their prices do not always move in step with shares.

The mix varies from fund to fund, from mostly bonds to mostly shares, and more in shares means bigger swings in value. Some are built from index trackers, and where a fund holds other funds or ETFs, their costs are counted in its ongoing charge.

This type suits people who want one fund and no rebalancing, which means moving money back to the chosen mix after prices shift. It is a poor fit for someone who wants to set their own mix. It is not low-risk by default: a fund that is mostly shares can fall almost as far as a share tracker, and bonds can fall in value too.

When to get advice

This guide describes types of fund. It cannot say which, if any, fits your circumstances. That is regulated advice, and it comes from an FCA-authorised adviser. Do you need a financial adviser? explains what one does and what it costs.

Common questions

What is an index fund?

An index fund buys the companies in a market index instead of paying a manager to pick some, aiming for the index's return less its costs. Trackers differ by index, accumulation or income units, fund or ETF, and charges.

How do I invest in index funds?

ISA, pension or general account is a separate choice about tax and access. Index funds can be held in all three. Compare the index, accumulation or income units, fund or ETF, and the ongoing charge, which comes off the whole pot every year.

Can I lose money in an index fund?

Yes. A tracker falls as far as its market falls. You may get back less than you put in, and past performance is not a reliable guide to the future. Money needed within about five years is generally not money to invest.

Work it out

Sources

Information, not advice. Save Sterling publishes general information and calculators, not financial advice or personal recommendations. We are not authorised or regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority. Tax rules depend on your circumstances and can change. Save Sterling has the same owner as Earn Sterling, which earns commission from some of what it lists, and Student Sterling, which may earn commission. Last reviewed . How we write and check guides

Get one money-saving bill tip a week

Get one money-saving bill tip a week. Optional, and you can unsubscribe at any time.

We will store your email address and the page you signed up from to send that weekly tip. You can unsubscribe at any time. The address is stored in Cloudflare. Read our privacy notice.